Personalised Medicine: The Pros and Cons

Since the Human Genome Project (HGP) was essentially completed in April 2003 there have been vast improvements in DNA sequencing technology, making whole-genome sequencing (WGS) both technically and economically feasible.

In October 2006, the X- prize foundation united with the J. Craig Venter Science Foundation to offer the ‘Archon X Prize’; a $10 million reward to the team that can build a machine capable of efficiently and effectively sequencing the human genome for less than $1000. Competition is high and companies are expected to reach this goal within a couple of years, making direct- to- consumer WGS affordable.

Is the large amount of information, generated by personal genome sequencing, entirely necessary?

Will WGS revolutionise modern health care?

One of the main areas that has had a high influx of investment by pharmaceutical companies is the development of ‘personalized medicines’. WGS can be used to predict a patient’s response to certain drugs or possible side effects. By identifying these pharmacogenomic variants, drugs and therapy can be tailored to the specific patient.

Another area of interest is the possibility of diagnosing a patient’s predisposition to disease, this previously would have only been possible by looking at family history. Geneticists will be able to reveal a person’s carrier status for autosomal recessive diseases and determine risk factors for certain adult- onset diseases. The ethical question is raised, whether to tell someone of a disease they will inevitably develop in later life? This may result in some life- style changes but could also result in unwanted psychological implications.

There are still many challenges to overcome before whole- genome sequencing is fully effective and useful in a clinical context. One difficult aspect is how to relay information to the patient; they must be adequately informed before they decide to be tested and must have appropriate counseling afterwards when they receive the results. For example, with the relative frequency of recessive autosomal diseases, patients must realize that there is a significant probability that they will possess at least one or multiple harmful recessive alleles. This information could influence a person’s reproductive decisions.

Awareness should also be brought to the underlying fact that there is uncertainty in the results, every mutation in a disease- causing gene only presents a ‘risk’ of developing the disease. Large areas of the genome still have unknown meaning; areas that could either exacerbate or counteract a certain disease- causing mutation.

Another continuing matter is the ever-expanding knowledge of genetic information. Although this may sound advantageous, it poses the problem that an assessment of an individual’s genome today may be redundant within the next year, as new discoveries and advances are made. Clinicians are then under the obligation to report this to the respective patients.

Building on this, is the issue of whether there is sufficient infrastructure in place to support the growing demand for WGS. Primarily, this lies in a shortage of specialist staff to interpret and convey results to patients. However, with increased computerization of the process and more efficient methods, this problem can be solved. Furthermore, to deliver a fully comprehensive report on an individual’s genome would require an accessible database with accurate information on all the known genetic diseases. This information is difficult to obtain and to keep up to date.

Drawing on the points highlighted, clearly there is a promising future in clinical WGS and the potential use of personalized medicines. Cost and capable machinery are now less of a limiting factor; we have transitioned into an era where ethics, legislation and the de-coding of genetic information are the greater obstacles. Once these associated issues have been resolved we will be able to reap the advantages and hopefully open a new door of modern healthcare.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: